Equator used to be my favorite page on the whole instagram. It showcases old photos from pre-digital era. Initially it showed mostly photos from the equatorial regions, as the handle would suggests, ocassionally some from East Asia and other regions. I liked it because it showed the beauty of places on the equator in the olden days. Because we are so used to perceived old traditional European culture as beautiful, or those of East Asia, but very rarely are we exposed to the beauty of old traditional culture of South East Asia, before it became the cities they are today with the ugliness of modernity.
I also liked it because it reminds me of intentional photography. Most photos we see today are from social media and most of them either are for engagement or to seek attention to oneself. Photos on equator reminds me of the photography I used to know, the one taken with intention, the one that is taken to tell a story, the one that celebrates life.
But then, one day around the end of last year, the page posted a very weird archeology photo of a giant leaf with a bunch of white men around it. It was a very strange photo and it has a long strange caption explaining the whole archeology thing. Soon after it was posted people flooded the post with comments suggesting that the page was sold and was run by someone else who now post AI generated images. Not long after the post was taken down with no further explanation. And it keeps posting old photos although nowadays it clearly no longer focus on the equatorial region.
After that one AI generated image, I found myself examining each of their posts more carefully, with suspicion about whether it really was an old photo taken by a photographer or another fake one. An then soon after I no longer care. I no longer put likes on their posts like I used to, I just see and scroll past through. A lot of people today still don't see the problem with generative AI and I am unable to convince them that art is meaningless without the intention, without the process. That it is meaningless when it's not created by human. The point of people viewing old archival photographs is to see how people live in the old days, what it was like, how it might feels. What do you actually get by viewing a fake archeological leaf photo?
I fully realized that AI is here to stay and it's going to get even more sophisticated and I don't actually know what we should do about it. Then there's AI that is not genAI. AI is not not useful. AI is sometimes useful to make things efficient when you're already smart enough to know how to use it without wholly swallowing everything it tells you. But the way people are embracing it full on makes me think that we are totally heading to be a dumber and less humane society. And it is scary.
































